|
General Catholic
Papacy
- Conversation
with the "Hotmail" Fathers on Infallibility - Two
intelligent Evangelical Baptists named (ironically) Athanasius of
Alexandria and Gregory of Nyssa discuss the nature of authority,
infallibility, the Church and Sola Scriptura with some prominent
Internet Catholic apologists, my contributions are included
- Gallicanism
- The Papacy
- Papal
Infallibility
- Peter
And The Papacy
- Was
Peter In Rome?
- The Primacy Of The Pope In The Church
- Who
Is The Rock?
- "What is
the story of Joan of Arc, and does it make a dent in
infallibility?"
- "Is it
true that the Greek Orthodox Church believes in infallibility, but
not in the Catholic sense?"
- "Papal
infallibility can't be true because Pope Zozimus pronounced Pelagius
to be orthodox and later reversed himself. What do you have to say
to that?"
- "Isn't it
Christ, rather than Peter, who holds the key of David?"
- "Is it
true that Pope Gregory I denied that the pope is the 'universal
bishop' and taught that the Bishop of Rome has no authority over any
other bishop?"
- "How can
you say Peter had supreme authority when he referred to himself as
only the 'fellow elder' (1 Pet. 5:1) of other Church leaders?"
- Apostolic
Succession
- The
Primacy of Peter
- Peter
the Rock
- Peter
in Rome
- Peter's
Successors
- The
Authority of the Pope (Part I)
- The
Authority of the Pope (Part II)
- Was
St. Peter Ever in Rome? Refuting a Persistent Protestant Prejudice
- Why do many Evangelicals today continue to doubt Peter's presence
in Rome? -- from the humorous "Bateman on Trial" series
- An
Answer to James White on the Early Papacy
From the brilliant apologist Mark Bonocore of Catholic Apologetics
International, answers to ten questions on the early Papacy from
James White (his protege Jason Engwer has engaged in an online
debate with Mark on the Papacy, see below)
- An
Email Debate on the Early Papacy: Mark Bonocore vs. Jason Engwer
- Debates the proposition: "Was the Papacy established by
Christ?"
- Jesus,
Peter, and the Keys: James White's Objections Answered - some of
the best Catholic replies to James White on the primacy of St. Peter
and the Papacy, includes a critique by David Palm of White's review
of Jesus, Peter and the Keys by Scott Butler et al (Queenship
Publishing 1996), and Robert Sungenis and David Palm on the language
of Matthew 16
- Stumbling
Upon This Rock: Steve Ray Answers Bill Webster - Stephen Ray,
author of the excellent Upon This Rock, in a massive response
demolishes anti-Catholic critic William Webster's
"rebuttal" -- covers in great detail St. Augustine, St.
John Chrysostom, Tertullian, Origen, St. Cyprian, St. Ambrose, much
more -- appendix on Cardinal Newman, the Eastern Fathers, Vatican
Council I and Unanimous Consent -- AWESOME! -- this is a link to the
index of articles for Steve Ray's response
- Refutation
of Webster's Fundamental Misunderstanding of Development of Doctrine
- Dave Armstrong responds in detail to William Webster's recent
anti-Papal article on his site
- Dialogue
on Development of Doctrine and the Papacy - From an Email
exchange with William Webster on development, Vatican Council I, and
Leo XIII encyclical Satis Cognitum
- Pope
Gregory the Great and the "Universal Bishop" Controversy
- What did Pope Gregory I in his letters to John the Faster
(Patriarch of Constantinople) mean by "universal bishop" ?
Was he really denying his own papal authority? Debunks a popular
anti-Catholic myth perpetuated by modern Evangelical apologists
- St.
Augustine, Pelagianism, and the Holy See - From Studies on the
Early Papacy by the superb patristic scholar Dom John Chapman,
demonstrates the clear recognition of Papal primacy, authority and
infallibility in the early Church, and discusses in great detail the
history of the Pelagian heresy, the role of St. Augustine (the
origin of the famous saying "Rome has spoken; the case is
closed"), the African bishops, and the Popes (Innocent I and
Zosimus)
- Pope
Zosimus and Pelagianism - Part 2 of the above article from Fr.
Chapman, discusses the history of the Pelagian heresy after Pope
Innocent, answers the common non-Catholic objection that the
controversy between Pope Zosimus and the African Bishops contradicts
Papal infallibility
- St.
Cyprian on the Church and the Papacy - More from Studies on the
Early Papacy by Fr. Chapman, a study of Cyprian of Carthage in
response to Anglican scholars (answers as well modern anti-Catholic
Evangelicals like James White and William Webster who inconsistently
use these old Anglican arguments)
Church Authority
Mary & Other Saints
- Prayer and the
Saints
- Immaculate
Conception and Assumption
- The
Rosary
- FAQ about
Mary
- Saint
Worship?
- The
Key to Understanding Mary
- Mary's
Virginity and the Talmud
- Jerome's
Against Helividius
- "What is
the answer to a friend who says we are worshiping the Babylonian
goddess Ishtar when we honor Mary? He uses Jeremiah 44 as proof
because we call Mary the Queen of heaven."
- "The bible
says the sins of the fathers are visited on their children down to
the fourth generation. How do you square this with Mary's Immaculate
Conception, given she had a sinful human father?"
- "A speaker
on the 'Bible Answer Man' radio program denied Mary's perpetual
virginity. He claimed that James, called one of the brothers of the
Lord in Matthew 13:55, was one of Mary's 'other' sons. He insisted
that it was a different James who was the son of Mary the wife of
Cleophas--this Mary stood at the foot of the cross (John
19:25)."
- "As the
'ark of the new covenant,' isn't Mary worshiped by Catholics in the
same way that the old ark of the covenant was worshiped by
Israel?"
- "Aren't
the images of Mary with the baby Jesus taken from pagan
representations of goddesses with children? If not, how do you
explain the fact that so many cultures have woman-with-child images
in their religion?"
- "When did
the custom of canonizing saints start, and is it true that
canonizations are infallible?"
- The
Communion of Saints
- Luther on Mary
- Mary:
The Mother of God
- Mary,
the Mother of Jesus
- Mary:
Ever Virgin
- Mary:
Full of Grace
- Praying
to the Saints
- The
Perpetual Virginity of our Lady
A defense of the Catholic belief in the Blessed Virgin Mary,
examines the biblical texts and historical views including the
original Protestant Reformers, Protestant scholars, and the Church
Fathers on perpetual virginity and Mother of God (Theotokos), from
an early discussion in PhileoNet theology
- Communion of
the Saints
- Dulia
Angels, Evil Spirits, and the Soul
Apparitions and Private Revelations
Purgatory & Hell
Baptism
Eucharist and Holy Mass
- The Eucharist
- A short explanation
- The
Eucharist
- Is there
a New Mass?(papal doc.)
- Why Was
the Mass Changed?(papal doc.)
- Introduction
to the Lefebvrist schism
- "If we eat
only the accidents (appearances), how do we eat Christ, who said
unless we eat his flesh and drink his blood (substances), we will
not have life?"
- "When I
read John 6 it seems obvious to me that Jesus was speaking of
'eating his flesh and drinking his blood' in a purely symbolic
way."
- "How can
Catholics say Christ does not die again on the altar when the
Council of Trent states that he is immolated in the Mass?"
- "Does the
Catholic Church accept other theologies of the Eucharist besides
transubstantiation?"
- "I know of
a priest who, during the consecration, used to say 'This is our
bread of life' instead of 'This is my body.' Was this valid? What if
the priest makes only minor variations in the words? How much must
be there for the consecration to be valid?"
- "What is
the Eucharistic 'sacrifice'? And when Jesus said, 'Do this in memory
of me,' what was 'this'?"
- "Why do
Catholics kneel at Mass?"
- "Are lay
people now allowed to give homilies?"
- "At Mass,
are the people supposed to say the Per Ipsum ('Through him,
with him, in him . . .') along with the priest?"
- "In the
Latin Mass, which is the correct translation for 'pro multis': 'for
many' or 'for all'?"
- "Are
little children required to go to Mass on Sunday?"
- The
Body of Christ
- Who
Can Receive the Eucharist?
- The
Real Presence
- The Mass
- The
Sacrifice of the Mass
Confession
Confirmation
Annointing of the Sick
Holy Matrimony
Holy Orders
Sacramentals/Holy Objects
- Relics
- "Is there
any biblical basis for the Catholic use of holy water?"
- "What
about the claim that the brown scapular is the 'assurance of
salvation'?"
- The
Sacramentals
- Talks on
the Sacramentals (Long)
- Born
Again: Baptism in the Early Fathers - Proof that the earliest
Christians unanimously held a Catholic view of the Sacrament of
Baptism, as even Protestant scholars admit
- This
is My Body: Eucharist in the Early Fathers - Proof that the
earliest Christians unanimously held a Catholic view of the Holy
Eucharist as to Real Presence and Sacrifice, covers the biblical
evidence and the major Fathers and early ecclesiastical writers
before St. Augustine (ante 400 AD)
- Reply
to Evangelical Critics of the Eucharist and the Fathers - After
reading the above, you can check out my reply to prominent
Evangelical/Fundamentalist Protestant critics of the Eucharist, such
as Norm Geisler/Ralph MacKenzie Roman Catholics and Evangelicals,
and others such as James White, William Webster, Eric Svendsen
- Tertullian,
St. Cyprian, Origen, and St. Clement of Alexandria on the Eucharist
- Analysis of Tertullian and Cyprian (some claim they held purely
"symbolical" views), and Origen and Clement of Alexandria
(who used more allegorical methods of biblical interpretation),
response to an anti-Catholic of FidoNet (David Goforth) who relies
heavily on Philip Schaff
- St.
Augustine on the Eucharist
Examination of the complex view of this great Father and Saint on
the Holy Eucharist as to Real Presence and Sacrifice, more of my
response to David Goforth, many statements from Protestant scholars
Philip Schaff, JND Kelly, and Darwell Stone to demonstrate the clear
Catholic view of Augustine
The Last Things
Miscellaneous Catholic
Beliefs
|